Question

Which is larger - a quark or an electron?

Asked by: Ann Gartner

Answer

Another very fundamental question with a very counter-intuitive answer. We all tend to ask such questions because our mental picture of subatomic particles is plain wrong. This is because the behavior of such particles do not resemble our daily experience at all. When we try to picture an electron, it turns out we mostly think of it as a 'very small steel ball'. But in fact, it is _not_ a steel ball at all, and it resembles nothing we have 'seen'.

Here is my partly physical and partly philosophical understanding: In order to be able to talk about a 'size', you need at least two particles. The proton for example, does indeed have a size, but this is because it has internal structure -- it is made up of other particles. The same goes for the atom, it consists of electrons and a nucleus. However, if you have a truly fundamental particle at hand, there is no way you can assign a size to it.

As far as we know (see http://www.physlink.com/Education/AskExperts/ae114.cfm), electrons and quarks are fundamental particles, thus have no size. The "as far as we know" part here is important, because it might turn out that these particles do have internal structure, and are composed of other, 'more fundamental' particles. Electrons have so far resisted all attempts to find a hint of internal structure. With quarks, there is the further trouble that free quarks do not exist in nature, making experiments to probe their internal structure (if any) more difficult.

So, finally, you may ask, which is larger - a quark, or an electron? Neither has a known size, they are apparently both point particles. If they are indeed both point particles, the question does not apply. If they are not point particles, the answer is that I do not know...

Answered by: Yasar Safkan, Ph.D., Software Engineer, Noktalar A.S., Istanbul, Turkey

Search

Loading


Support Discovery Capsule - Anton's new project on Kickstarter.



Science Quote

'An expert is someone who knows some of the worst mistakes that can be made in his subject and how to avoid them.'

Werner Heisenberg
(1901-1976)
Science Sidebar | Science Education Articles
Cool Summer Science Projects

Why not make science a part of your family’s summer? Perhaps you can set aside one day a week for outdoor projects—maybe Mad Scientist Monday or Scientific Saturday? Here are a few ideas to help get you started. Continue reading ...

10 Ways to Keep Your Kids Interested In Science

Young children are natural scientists: they ask questions, pick up sticks and bugs outside, and are curious about the world around them. But as they get a bit older, many kids gradually lose their interest in science. They might see it as just another task at school, something that doesn't apply to their lives. Of course nothing could be further from the truth, so here are ten ways you can remind your kids that science is everywhere. Most of these are fun for adults, too! Continue reading ...

Top Selling

Here are our physics & astronomy bestsellers:
Magnetic Levitator - Classic
Scorpion, Ant, Wasp and Flower Bug
12 inch Galileo Thermometer
Revolving Multi-Color Fiberoptic Light
Solar Radiometer
Enviro Battery 4M Kit
Tin Can Robot 4M Kit
Wood Grain Newtons Cradle
Brush Robot 4M Kit
Electric Plane Launcher 4M Kit

Sponsors

USC University of Southern California Dornsife College Physics and Astronomy Department McMaster University Physics and Astronomy Department