Please can you (briefly) tell me how the concept of 'non locality', or what Einstein referred to as 'spooky
action at a distance' was arrived at?
Asked by: George Jackson
While I'm not a historian of science, the concept of action-at-a-distance probably originates with
Newton's law of Universal Gravitation. Prior to Newton all of physics (indeed all of science
generally) was conceived of in purely mechanical terms. Everything from the motion of the planets
to visual perception was described in terms of particles bouncing off of one another, translating
their kinetic motion from one body to another. Thus, all action was inherently 'local' (two objects
have to be at the same point in space and time to collide).
Newton's law of gravity says that a given mass influences every other mass with a strength
inversely proportional to the square of the distance separating them. There is no intercession of
particle collisions or anything of the sort. In fact, the influence was to be taken as an
instantaneous effect. Thus the sun influences the earth's motion though the two are physically and
With relativity theory and quantum physics together we now know that something does in fact
propagate between the two bodies -- namely, gravitational waves whose quanta are called gravitons.
In fact we now know that all forces are mediated by such quanta called gauge bosons (such as
photons) that can be thought of as being emitted by one body and absorbed by the other in a
constant process of 'exchange.' Thus quantum field theory brings us back to 'local' forces.
Modern preoccupation with action-at-a-distance (to which Einstein objected) revolves around a
purely quantum phenomenon. This is the celebrated thought experiment in which an 'entangled' system
of two objects is created. The wavefunction of object #1 is correlated with the wavefunction of
object #2. By the axioms of quantum mechanics a measurement of the properties of object #1 forces
its wavefunction to collapse, instantly implying a correlated collapse in object #2 though it be
arbitrarily far away. Though no information can be passed using such a method (thus not coming into
conflict with special relativity) it does seem to imply some action-at-a-distance that is NOT
accounted for by the exchange of force-mediating quanta such as gravitons or photons. This
continues to be an unsettling state of affairs and a focus of philosophical and physical research,
as it was for Einstein and as it was for the philosophers of Newton's day who were equally troubled
Answered by: Brent Nelson, M.A. Physics, Ph.D. Student, UC Berkeley
'As far as the laws of mathematics refer to reality, they are not certain; and as far as they are certain, they do not refer to reality.'