What happens when a tablecloth is pulled out from underneath a table setting, and
everything on the table stays put?
Asked by: K. Devereux
In that demonstration, the tableware is exhibiting Newton's laws of motion.
Newton's first law says that the tableware will remain motionless unless acted upon by an
outside force. To set the objects on the table into motion, the horizontal force acting
upon them in this case is the frictional force between them and the table cloth.
Newton's second law says the amount of force needed to accelerate the tableware is directly
related to the rate of acceleration. When the tablecloth is pulled slowly, the tableware
matches its low rate of acceleration and moves along with it. When the cloth is pulled
quickly, the tableware needs to accelerate at a greater rate to move along with it; but the
force needed to make that happen is greater than the frictional force available an it
lags behind. If the cloth is pulled very rapidly, the tableware 'stays put.'
Answered by: Paul Walorski, B.A. Physics, Part-time Physics Instructor
This question touches on one of the most mysterious things in our universe! The simple
answer to your question is inertia. In other words, when you pull the table cloth off the
table full of dishes the dishes stay put because of inertia. Inertia is the property of
matter that describes its resistance to any change in its motion. When you are running and
you try to turn you notice that it is harder to turn the faster you run or the bigger you
become the harder it is to change direction. These are other examples of inertia. When
you are riding in a car and the driver turns a corner, the feeling that you are being
pushed into the door or over to the driver is another example of inertia.
But, what exactly, IS this tendency of things to 'want' to stay as they are? Why does all
matter have this property? Why does the amount of matter affect the amount of inertia?
Did you know that you could measure the mass of an object by its inertia? In fact, the
inertial mass of any object exactly equals the gravitational mass of the object. Einstein
himself could not explain this relationship!
If your mother is like mine and will not let you pull a table cloth out from under her
dishes you could use a sheet of paper and some coins. If you place the sheet of paper on
the edge of a table with three or four inches hanging off the edge you can lick your finger
and quickly strike the paper with a downward motion which will slide the paper out from
under the coins without the coins moving. This is even more fun when you try to see how
many coins you can stack up or how many coins you can put on their edges and have still
I would like to end with one quick word of warning. I have learned from hard experience
that if you do try the table cloth demonstration, be sure that the table cloth does not
have a raised hem around the edge! I hope this answer helped and I hope it raised more
Answered by: Tom Young, M.S., Science Teacher, Whitehouse High School
'There is no inductive method which could lead to the fundamental concepts of physics. Failure to understand this fact constituted the basic philosophical error of so many investigators of the nineteenth century.'