By what method is the size (or volume) of the universe at the moment of the big bang (or shortly thereafter) determined? Related to this, how is the size of a black hole determined?
Asked by: Todd Andresen
Actually, we really don't know the absolute size of the universe right now, but the 'Big
Bang' is defined as the point when the universe had zero volume. The way it works is
that we know, from experiments that the universe is expanding. We've even managed to measure
the expansion rate moderately well. So we look for solutions of Einstein's equations of
general relativity that have an expanding, homogeneous and isotropic universe. To solve this
we need to know the expansion rate today (which we know) and the size today (which we don't
really know). However, we can solve for the ratio of the size at some past (or
future) time to the size today. If you solve the equation for the time in the past when the
ratio was zero, you call that the time of the 'Big Bang' and you've just computed the age of
So the basic answer is that we can't really measure the absolute size of the universe (much
of which may even be outside our current horizon) but we can solve for the size relative to
the size today.
As for black holes, their size is determined in a completely different way. By the 'size' of
a black hole we typically mean the Schwarzschild radius (or 'event horizon' as people like
to say). This radius is determined solely by the mass of the black hole and is given by:
We can then measure the size of the black hole by measuring it's gravitational attraction
with other objects near it (like stars) -- and hence its mass.
Answered by: Brent Nelson, M.A. Physics, Ph.D. Student, UC Berkeley
'In a way science is a key to the gates of heaven, and the same key opens the gates of hell, and we do not have any instructions as to which is which gate.
Shall we throw away the key and never have a way to enter the gates of heaven? Or shall we struggle with the problem of which is the best way to use the key?'