What is the difference between cathode rays and beta rays since both are basically electrons?
Asked by: Kavita
The two differently named 'rays' you mention not only consist of the same thing, note
that they aren't even rays! Blame the imprecise labels partly on the fact that they were
named before their true nature was understood.
Even before the electron was discovered, cathode 'rays' were observed in electrical
experiments because of their fluorescent effect near a negatively charged plate (called the
cathode) in a vacuum. They were only later found to be negatively charged electrons emitted
from negatively charged plates and accelerating toward positively charged ones. (Like
charges repel, unlike charges attract.)
Beta 'rays' were first observed being emitted from certain unstable (radioactive) isotopes,
and behaved unlike the alpha and gamma radiation also found in radioactivity. It wasn't
until later that both alpha and beta 'radiation' were discovered to actually be
particles; only gamma rays consist of true electromagnetic radiation. Beta 'rays' are
actually electrons ejected from decaying neutrons, and are now more often referred to as
Beta emission or Beta particles.
So electrons can be described differently, not based on WHAT they are but HOW they are
created or observed. You may want to add cosmic 'rays' to your list, which can also contain
electrons coming to Earth from space! And what about 'static electricity', 'lightning',
'electric current', etc? Those electrons do get around, don't they? And if you think that
only physics has imperfect nomenclature, ask a room full of astronomers whether Pluto is a
planet or an asteroid!
Answered by: Paul Walorski, B.A. Physics, Part-time Physics Instructor
'In a way science is a key to the gates of heaven, and the same key opens the gates of hell, and we do not have any instructions as to which is which gate.
Shall we throw away the key and never have a way to enter the gates of heaven? Or shall we struggle with the problem of which is the best way to use the key?'